Home > ac > How precise is the frequency of the AC electricity network?

How precise is the frequency of the AC electricity network?

February 13Hits:1

If I make a digital clock which first detects the AC frequency roughly (whether it is 50, 60, 100Hz, etc), then uses it as its clock pulse source, how precise would it be? Would it work world wide precisely?

For instance, in USA, what is the mean and standard deviation of the 60Hz AC frequency?

Grid frequency will change throughout the day due to imbalance between electricity generation and consumption.

Grid operator is obligated to keep the frequency within +/- 0.5Hz of 50Hz (frequency and range depends on the country's grid codes). When you measure time based on the assumption that every period is equal to 20ms you will have a time deviation error that. This error is kept within certain bounds by the network operators. If the time deviation is too big, a frequency compensation is scheduled to compensate it.

You can find public data about current grid frequency online e.g. Swiss and UK grids. The Swiss website also shows the current time deviation.

This post on hackaday links to this interesting article where someone investigates the accuracy of 60Hz mains frequency over time, I hope it might help.

One thing it shows for certain is that the AC line is definitely not a steady frequency, but it varies over time. It also shows that the frequency seems to flutter a lot more abruptly during peak hours of the day. At night, it changes much more slowly.

As a possible explanation, I've heard that electric utility companies know that many customers depend on that 60Hz to keep their clocks going accurately, but it's difficult to keep the 60Hz exact when energy demand is fluctuating rapidly.

As a solution, they will adjust the frequency slightly during off-peak hours to compensate for any mishaps during the day.

The conclusion seems to be that the frequency probably averages out quite accurately, but will fluctuate depending on the time of day, as a result of the load on the network.

There's some interesting links at the bottom of the article to further reading and experiments. I also seem to remember another article posted via hackaday which also looked at the same topic, but I can't seem to find it now.

It'll be something like +/-0.5 Hz maximum, and during the day I noticed a clock drift by a minute or two, but the long term average error will be zero; the utilities presumably reference it to time standards.

Observing the instantaneous frequency is one way to compare supply and demand. If the frequency drops, the utilities will bring more power on line to maintain it.

There was a fascinating news story on this topic recently: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-20629671

In short, the London Metropolitan Police forensic lab has recorded the variations in AC frequency for the last 7 years in the UK National Grid, and use it to validate any claimed audio recordings were recorded contiguously during the stated period.

"While the frequency of the electricity supplied by the national grid is about 50Hz, if you look at it over time, you can see minute fluctuations in the order of a few thousandths of a hertz."

My Romanian (or was it the Polish guy.. Quite some time ago) friend claimed they would reduce the frequency to slow things down and save power. He might have been telling a joke, but it was pretty dead-pan.

Wikipedia indicates that the US grid operators intervene to bring the count back when it's drifted by 2 , 3 , or 10 seconds (West, Texas, and East grids) from the 60hz long term target used for time keeping. However, 2 years ago regulators authorized an experiment to see what would happen if the adjustments stopped being made. I haven't been able to find what the results were and if they changed regulation permanently in response to it.

Related Articles

• How precise is the frequency of the AC electricity network?February 13

If I make a digital clock which first detects the AC frequency roughly (whether it is 50, 60, 100Hz, etc), then uses it as its clock pulse source, how precise would it be? Would it work world wide precisely? For instance, in USA, what is the mean and

• Importance of keeping the electricity network frequency stableApril 3

The frequency in the electricity network is kept in balance by primary and secondary control among others (see e. g. here). I read that frequencies below 47.5 Hertz are dangerous and can lead to destruction of generators due to resonance oscillations

• Precise measuring of frequency with high-speed ADCJanuary 8

Let's say I have precise "reference" clock and I want to measure frequency of some other "target" clock, as precisely (let's say ~12-15 digits) and as fast as possible. In the simplest case one might just count periods, but solution wi

• Need help deriving cutoff frequency of output (collector) RC networkJuly 16

According to the book I'm studying, the cutoff frequency for this circuit is given by $$f_c=\frac{1}{2\pi(R_C+R_L)C_3}.$$ I tried to derive it by solving for the frequency at which \$V_{out}\$ is \$V_{collector}/\sqrt{2}\$: \frac{V_{collector}R_L}{

• VPN on OSX disconnects after precisely 2 minutes and 30 seconds on specific networkFebruary 2

When connecting to my own VPN server on a specific network, called public-network, my Mac disconnects the VPN connection after 2 minutes and 30 seconds. I have performed several tests and this is the result: It works fine until the 2:30 mark It doesn

• PLL - why compare phases not frequenciesJune 26

I have a question about PLL's. The aim of PLL is to get two signals with the same frequencies (there can be a shift in phases, as I understand). So, in this case, why do you use a phase detector to compare phases, and NOT just compare frequencies? th

• Can I buy a motor that vibrates or pulses very precisely?November 23

I'm trying to make an item with a number of pads that will pulse individually or in sequence with a given signal. I have looked at vibration motors but these are like the ones in video game controllers - they vibrate but the duration is too long. I w

• Change Logitech Unifying Reciever Frequency Band?May 10

Recently, I bought a Logitech M570 Wireless Trackball Mouse. While I am very happy with it overall, one issue is nagging me. Every so often, the mouse will experience a input lag, so movement is jumpy instead of smooth. This can be very annoying when

• Analog Telephone Frequency Response CurveJuly 18

Old analog telephone circuits using carbon microphones seem to be said to have a frequency response of, from various low frequencies which differing reports put at between 275 Hz and 400 Hz, up to various high frequencies, reportedly between 3 and 3.

• Frequency transported via electric cableSeptember 21

Newbie here, a (home-made) computer technician. So here is my question, frequency (megahertz) is not electric? But sound waves? Is this correct? A close friend, an electrical engineer, explained to me that broadband megahertz was a type of audio, and

• Limiting wired low frequency signal transmissionApril 13

I'm now considering TDA5051A to transmit information over the 230VAC power network. To avaid any interference between neightbours I will need to stop transmision beyond the appartment electrical network. As I understand from its datasheet the transmi

• Achieving 'frequency separation' in wireless networksAugust 10

A popular recommendation from security providers is to ensure wireless networks achieve 'frequency separation' from other wireless networks. What does 'frequency separation' mean in technical terms and what steps could an organisation take to achieve

• Exceeding Relay maximum switching frequencyNovember 4

I read in the datasheet of the DOLD OA5611 that the maximum relay cycles/s is 10 cycles/s. Now I want to know what are the risks for the relay if I control it with a switching frequency more than 10 Hz. It's not specified in the datasheet what the co

• How to select/lock cell network frequency band?January 20

I am developing a very specialized piece of software for Android and I need the capability to select and lock on to a specific frequency band within the cell network. Does anyone know a way of doing this. I realize there is no API, but maybe by issui

• What is the ppm in the crystal oscillator?June 23

I'm a student and I'm working on a low power communication project. I am trying to design a PCB using the TI CC2540 sample design. There is a MC-306 (32.768kHz, 12.5pf, and 20/50ppm). I don't know what the 20/50ppm rating is. For me, the size is very

• How does this capacitor work in this schematic?October 14

So I'm looking at an AVR Programmers and setup and I see this schematic: How exactly does this work? (Keep in mind I'm a newbie at schematics), but the way the schematic looks makes it seem like that a separate 22pF capacitor should go on each side.

• Synchronise crystal oscillator with external short burstMay 17

I am trying to generate a stable 4.43361875 MHz clock (i.e. PAL colourburst) synchronised to the colourburst of a PAL video signal. In a PAL signal the colourburst is provided for only about 8-10 cycles near the beginning of each line. So, I need a w

• How can I convert the current from a fan to the microphone headset input on an iphone?July 27

I am working on creating an anemometer (or wind meter) for the iPhone. I am a programmer and know exactly how I could do this on the software side of things, but I am a complete noob when it comes to electronics. I have seen many other posts about pu

• Confusion over clocks in FPGAs / VerilogNovember 24

I just purchased an FPGA and I am learning Verilog but I have run into a few confusions, most of them regarding the clock. My first question is, how does sequential logic work? Are the assignments made, one per clock cycle, or does the sequencing som

• Quartz oscillator using a large irregular (natural) piece of quartz crystal for maximum Q?June 23

Background Based on helpful comments and links here and also from my question on the physics stackexchange, I have learned that the quartz crystals are nature's transducers of energy, allowing electrical energy to be converted into mechanical energy