Home > resistors > What is the drawback of a high-value resistor for positive comparator feedback / hysteresis?

What is the drawback of a high-value resistor for positive comparator feedback / hysteresis?

October 27Hits:1
Advertisement

I'm building a simple circuit which has an LM211 comparator at its heart. The positive input is connected to a 10k-10k resistor divider across the supplies, stabilized by a 1uF capacitor. Hysteresis is provided by 1.8MOhm from the output to the positive input.

The signal on the SENS line is a slowly changing resistance hooked up to +5V on the other side.

What is the drawback of a high-value resistor for positive comparator feedback / hysteresis?

Everything works perfectly on a breadboard, but I wanted to check a few things before finalizing the board layout, and came across a TI application note which says in paragraph 6:

It is a standard procedure to use hysteresis (positive feedback) around a comparator, to prevent oscillation, and to avoid excessive noise on the output because the comparator is a good amplifier for its own noise. In the circuit of Figure 2, the feedback from the output to the positive input will cause about 3 mV of hysteresis. However, if the value of Rs is larger than 100Ω, such as 50 kΩ, it would not be reasonable to simply increase the value of the positive feedback resistor above 510 kΩ.

However, it doesn't say why a high value feedback resistor is "not reasonable". I built up my circuit on a breadboard, and it seems to work fine, I can definitely see good hysteresis behaviour with the 1M8 resistor as compared to without it.

So, what is the drawback?

Answers

Olin is right about the problem with C23: it lowers the bandwidth of the positive feedback rendering it useless. Just decoupling the supply close to the divider will do the job.

In fact, that is probably also the reason why TI wants to keep the feedback resistance low in value. If the value is too high, the input capacitance of the op-amp alone will already lower the bandwidth of the positive feedback, so on a noisy signal the hysteresis will not work. Normally you would like the hysteresis to be faster than the response of the op-amp; this will be probably be the 510K TI talks about.

If you make sure the highest (noise) frequency that can reach the negative input will be lower than the feedback response, you should be in the clear; however, making the feedback faster then the op-amp can react will be the better option.

1 MΩ for the positive feedback should be fine in your case from a impedance point of view. Whether it always provides enough positive feedback under all conditions is something you have to decide.

What bothers me about your circuit is that the positive feedback is fighting against C23. That is going to slow it down, which probably in part defeats its purpose. To fix this, you can add some resistance between C23 and the + input. The immediate effect of the positive feedback will be based on the feedback resistance and this deliberate resistance. In the long term, the 5 kΩ impedance of the power supply divider will be added to the deliberate series resistance.

You can parallel the 1M8 resistor with 2.7nF and avoid the objections while still maintaining a 1uF filter cap.

That's maintaining the 1800K/5K ratio of feedback resistance.

Related Articles

  • What is the drawback of a high-value resistor for positive comparator feedback / hysteresis?

    What is the drawback of a high-value resistor for positive comparator feedback / hysteresis?October 27

    I'm building a simple circuit which has an LM211 comparator at its heart. The positive input is connected to a 10k-10k resistor divider across the supplies, stabilized by a 1uF capacitor. Hysteresis is provided by 1.8MOhm from the output to the posit

  • Sending out a "Request for Comment" when establishing a new guidelineMarch 10

    Do you send out a "request for comment" when establishing a new company guideline or standard? Companies need to establish consistent guidelines on things like development process, version control, release procedures, etc. Is it worth the effort

  • Using microcontroller as oscillator for high voltage power suppy?

    Using microcontroller as oscillator for high voltage power suppy?August 20

    MightyOhm has designed a geiger counter which is here. I am not very clear but I think he is using the 555 timer as an oscillator in the high voltage power supply section. I've attached his schematic below. My question is can the design be changed to

  • Is Nagios "monitoring" over WAN ideal?January 24

    Just started at a new company and one my first assignments is to look for alternatives to their inhouse monitoring system. Their current solution is a .Net application that checks various devices over the WAN (since they are an IT-consulting firm tha

  • When to use Hadoop, HBase, Hive and Pig?December 17

    What are the benefits of using either Hadoop or HBase or Hive ? From my understanding, HBase avoids using map-reduce and has a column oriented storage on top of HDFS. Hive is a sql-like interface for Hadoop and HBase. I would also like to know how Hi

  • What exactly does ram get used for? January 6

    I know this sounds like a simple question, but I have searched everywhere and they just say " store data to be used more quickly". I know ram gets used to load programs into, but is the whole program loaded into it or just part? --------------So

  • DC-DC Buck Regulator: Embedded or External MOSFETJanuary 23

    What are benefits and drawbacks of using Buck Regulator with external MOSFET compared to Buck with embedded MOSFET? Is there some general rule? In my case I need 5V 3A from 9V-30V supply. --------------Solutions------------- The differences are large

  • When using deferred rendering technique, what space should my normals be? Why?October 2

    I'm implementing a deferred shading technique and the following question arose: When storing the normals, should I transform to view space, or may I keep them in world space? Why? Will any of the alternatives be better than the other for calculating

  • How can I maintain the current page nodes for portrait when temporarily entering landscape mode in TikZ?

    How can I maintain the current page nodes for portrait when temporarily entering landscape mode in TikZ?February 5

    Question How can I keep the current page nodes aligned with the same physical corners of the page in a document where the main layout is portrait, but some pages with longtable are in the landscape environment. In other words, how can I rotate the no

  • Servo Motion DirectionMarch 30

    I am trying to set up a servo controller that will automatically make the servo switch direction when it nears the end of its travel range. I designed a solution that uses a quad comparator and a peak detector to produce a useful control signal. The

  • How do I provide constant voltage to a load?August 12

    Say, I have 5V supply and I use voltage divider to have 2.5V and 2.5V across each of them. Suppose, I want to power a microcontroller (input impedance of 200Ω) which requires exactly 2.5V but once I connect it in parallel, the voltage across each com

  • Are there any drawbacks of "/3Gb" switch in boot.ini for 32bit Windows?June 17

    Microsoft advices to use /3Gb switch in Boot.ini in order to get more memory for a process running on 32bit system. Currently I need a lot of memory for devenv process (Visual Studio 2008) because I have a complex solution that has a lot of projects

  • 64 bit Vista drawbacks and problems?July 2

    What are common drawbacks, gotchas, and problems of choosing Vista 64-bit versus 32 bit? We recently purchased two laptops and selected Vista 64 bit, but I'm considering downgrading to Vista 32 bit on both. The only reason for going 64 bit was to get

  • Using inittab to ensure sshd (and other important items) are still running - any drawbacks?July 24

    Having managed to kill sshd on a remote machine (by running a script which used all available memory in the machine, oops...) which I have no access to other than visiting the hosting for[1], I was considering ways to ensure that sshd is always kept

  • Node Affinity and Load-Balancing - drawbacks?July 31

    What are the main drawbacks if we choose to use Node-Affinity (sticky MAC) with a load-balanced IIS solution? We are thinking about using in-memory Session State, so need to evaluate the options. Cheers Duncan --------------Solutions------------- You

  • Is there a drawback of having mod_expires installed?March 3

    I have a site on Godaddy Linux shared hosting and I wanted to improve caching for some elements, but apparently Godaddy did not install mod_expires. I see no other way to increase caching expiration for images and stuff (the default expiration time i

  • accessing external mysql server through "ssh tunnel" - any drawbacks?May 26

    In an upcoming project I have a two server setup: one is the application server and another, already existing runs the mysql server with databases I need to access. I contacted the server admin of the mysql server and the only way I can access the re

  • CNAME record for Amazon S3 - any drawbacks?August 20

    I'd like to make a CNAME record for my Amazon S3 domain, to have nicer URLs. There's not much discussion of this out there on the web, and nothing at all in the Amazon documentation (unless I'm missing it). Is this a reasonable thing to do? Are there

  • Drawbacks of XeTeX/LuaTeXSeptember 15

    Currently I use pdflatex to process my documents, but I want to be with the cool kids and switch to XeTeX or LuaTeX. My documents are moderately multilingual (main text in portuguese or english, quotations and references in english, german, french, r

  • What are the drawbacks of XeTeX/XeLaTeX vs standard LaTeX? September 15

    Currently I use pdflatex to process my documents, but I want to be with the cool kids and switch to XeTeX or LuaTeX. My documents are moderately multilingual (main text in portuguese or english, quotations and references in english, german, french, r

Copyright (C) 2017 ceus-now.com, All Rights Reserved. webmaster#ceus-now.com 14 q. 0.732 s.