Home > arcgis desktop > What is use of AutoCAD Map 3D, if we have ArcGIS Desktop?

What is use of AutoCAD Map 3D, if we have ArcGIS Desktop?

January 30Hits:5
Advertisement

What is the actual use of AutoCAD Map 3D?

It seems that ArcGIS Desktop has many tools for analysis.

Is there any other advantage in using AutoCAD Map 3D?

Answers

I partially agree with Devdatta Tehngshe,
Map3d was designed at rel2000 specifically for heads-up digitizing. (This has gotten much more sophisticated in recent versions.)

Argis 10 now has some features which make it "more" usable for that.

I have map3d and raster design I use to geo-reference images and save to geo-tiff which I use in all my applications proprietary and open.
I have several templates that it takes about 4 mins each to complete.

Doing the same thing in arcmap is not nearly so fast (not to mention I haven't figured a good way to make a template) and I have yet to find a good raster format that ESRI writes that Autodesk will read and georeference straight out.

There are many other functions which are not duplicated between the two. I can't live without both.

Direct export from Map3d gives infinitely more options than any of the capabilities of FME or ESRI.

In regards to the statements about autodesk not performing analysis.

The truth is that while autodesk does not embrace the same methodology for analysis as ESRI, autodesk is one of the most highly utilized analysis tools in all of the engineering disciplines and there are literally thousands of application, and scripts written to perform a wide range of analysis in all of the Autodesk applications.

Analysis of spatial properties of flood plain is used extensively with add-on products and has only recently (maybe 10 yrs) been developed for the ESRI product line. As of right now is not supported on the latest release. ESRI Forum Question

I would never put down ESRI, I use it daily, as I do Map3d. It does take some experieince to exploit the strengths of each and use them both as a tool in the belt, knowing which works best for which task.

AutoCAD Map is prefect for cleaning dwg files (spaghetti vector data) and preparing them for import for GIS applications. Also it is very good for georeferencing vector and raster data which can be pretty tedious in some GIS applications (not all of them). Generally, it is used for preparing data for GIS. You can us it as a GIS application, but it lacks lot of options and it not really suited for GIS. I don't think you can really compare ArcGIS and AutoCAD Map because they main purpose is not the same. Everyone has his benefits, ArcGIS can not replace AutoCAD Map nor AutoCAD Map can replace ArcGIS.

The main advantage as compared to ArcGIS is in digitizing vector data. I have seen that on average, completely digitizing an entire topo-sheet is 3 to 4 times faster with AutoCad MAP.

But once you have some vector data, editing it further in AutoCad Map is an tedious process and i would recommend sticking to ArcGIS Desktop.

While ArcGIS has a variety of powerful analytic tools, AutoCAD Map 3d offers a wide range of ways to convert from GIS features to CAD objects and vice versa. It is very good in collecting a huge variety of data on both geographical and project data, it is definately more interoperable compared to ArcGIS. It provides an opportunity to directly edit more types of entities than ArcGIS does. I like the both products, and anyway it is very useful to have AutoCAD Map even if you are shipped with ArcGIS...

I took courses for both programs, and during saw the use of MAP 3D applications easier than Arcgis (for Engineer) of the following aspects: 1- Drawings (lines, points, polyline, polygon,....). 2- cleanup drawing. 3- working with Survey data. 4- working with Raster Image. 5- Data Conversion. 6- Data editing. 7- Data management. 8- Styling and Theming Features.

Symbology and labeling engine is not nearly as robust in Autodesk Map. If you want to produce nice maps with quick cartographic representation then it's tough to find a product like Arcmap. I edit vector data in Autodesk Map 3D often as opposed to ArcMap - quicker with fewer mouse clicks although I use both.

Related Articles

  • What is use of AutoCAD Map 3D, if we have ArcGIS Desktop?January 30

    What is the actual use of AutoCAD Map 3D? It seems that ArcGIS Desktop has many tools for analysis. Is there any other advantage in using AutoCAD Map 3D? --------------Solutions------------- I partially agree with Devdatta Tehngshe, Map3d was designe

  • How to divide map into square grid using ArcGIS Desktop?March 1

    I want to divide a map in square grid using ArcGIS Desktop. Is it possible? --------------Solutions------------- Create a fishnet using the fishnet tool, then do an intersect procedure. The resulting data set will be a combination of your original da

  • Creating thematic map on calculated field in ArcGIS Desktop?January 31

    Is it possible to create a thematic map in ArcGIS Desktop on a calculated field, without changing the DBF file of the SHP file? I know I can do it in MapInfo, but have searched without much luck in ArcGIS Desktop. --------------Solutions-------------

  • Creating landslide susceptibility map using logistic regression and ArcGIS Desktop? September 14

    My project is to build a landslide susceptibility map using logistics regression. I have generated the following maps so far: slope map, hill shade, curvature, elevation, road buffers, river buffers of 100 - 500m , Aspect, land use land cover, ndvi.

  • AutoCAD map server's text to ArcGIS Annotation - SAFE FMEMay 14

    autocade Software: SAFE FME Geodatabase - enterprise geodatabase we have autocad data stored in oracle database and wishes to port them over to ArcGIS Annotation (text). We are unable to do so just by directly migration. after investigation we realiz

  • How to automatically export multiple maps with quantile symbology in ArcGIS Desktop?March 20

    I am a relatively new ArcGIS user and I have a question about automating a tedious join/symbology classification/export operation. I have a very simple shapefile to which I join a bunch of fields. I then need to have these new fields symbolized with

  • How to handle AutoCAD Map to QGIS workflow?

    How to handle AutoCAD Map to QGIS workflow?March 22

    I'm looking for some assistance and like many here, I am pretty much a GIS novice. I'm working on a project to map our local cemetery (about 40 acres), locating sections, lots, and graves, etc. I was able to obtain an aerial photo of the cemetery and

  • Transfering complex map symbology from ArcGIS Desktop using AutoCad Map object classes?June 26

    I'm trying to find the best way to transfer maps form ArcGIS to AutoCad Map. In ArcGIS map model is separated from it's representation. View is created by applying symbology and representation rules to underlying model. As far as I know this approach

  • How to affine in Autocad Map 3D 2010January 21

    We have several DWG files that we would like to use as Layers in GeoServer. Therefore, what is needed is to specify the coordinate of a certain point, rotate and scale the drawing prior to exporting it as SHP. By clicking on Tools and Geographic Loca

  • Connect AutoCAD Map 3D 2014 with MySQLJanuary 23

    I need to connect AutoCAD Map 3D 2014 with an Spatial MySQL database (version 5.5) but first I have to install "libmysql.dll" to connect as specified in the software user's manual. This file is currently inside MySQL 5.5 instalation folder. I've

  • Define line height for features in Autocad MapSeptember 5

    What is the procedure to assign a specific lineheight to a feature in Autocad Map. I understood the style definition but I can only assign a thickness between 0 and 5 instead I want a specific height (1mm). Thanks a lot

  • Why Autocad map consumes so slow WMS comparing with Arcgis or QGIS, and what can be done about that?November 17

    I created a WMS for aerial photo using Geoserver. Trying to use it with Autocad Map 3d 2013-2014-2015 Why this product consume so bad and slow this and every other WMS? While the bing aerial used by the same products its very fast. Can be done someth

  • Editing data in QGIS Server via WFS in AutoCAD Map (2015)

    Editing data in QGIS Server via WFS in AutoCAD Map (2015)June 9

    I have a QGIS Server up and running. I can consult my layers using WMS protocol and edit them using WFS protocol in QGIS or lizmap web client for example, but I am not able to make it work in AutoCAD Map. These are the steps I follow: In the third sc

  • Importing Mapinfo .TAB files to AutoCad MapFebruary 10

    It is any way to import Mapinfo files to Autocad Map with line and polygon style definitions cereated in Mapinfo? --------------Solutions------------- From Autodesk Map 3D Online Help: Importing MapInfo TAB Files You cannot import TAB symbol types di

  • How to Legally Use Google Imagery and Maps in ArcGIS Desktop and Web Applications? December 3

    Can I use Google Maps as a layer in ArcMap? Is it possible? --------------Solutions------------- Yes. ArcBruTile - Tile Services in ArcGIS Desktop ArcBruTile display tiles from OpenStreetMap, Bing, Google, SpatialCloud and TMS/WMS-C Services in ArcGI

  • Using newline/page break tag in ArcGIS Desktop Text_Element in arcpy.mapping?

    Using newline/page break tag in ArcGIS Desktop Text_Element in arcpy.mapping? February 23

    This question already has an answer here: Inserting newlines in Rectangle Text elements via ArcPy causes overlap? 2 answers I want to update a Text_Element with a newline or page break using ArcGIS Desktop 10.0. Does anyone know the tag or syntax? --

  • Majority filter (minimum mapping unit) in ArcGIS Desktop with larger window size?February 27

    I want to run the majority filter in ArcGIS Desktop with a window size of 4 or 5 i.e. greater than the default 3. Is it possible, or is there some other command (or tool) which might help me achieve that? --------------Solutions------------- A Focal

  • How to access Bing Map Metadata in ArcGIS Desktop?November 1

    Is there any way to access the metadata of Bing Maps in ArcGIS desktop? Any good plug-in or extension? --------------Solutions------------- Click the tiny chip at the bottom right corner of the map that has Bing data to get metadata for that extent.

  • Integrating ArcGIS Desktop and web map? May 21

    This question already has an answer here: How to Start Web Mapping? 26 answers I have some data that has been mapped in ArcGIS Desktop. I would like to develop something like if I add/change some parameters a new map can be derived so that it can be

  • Publishing maps and services to ArcGIS Server 9.3 when created by ArcGIS Desktop 10.0? [on hold]February 1

    We have license of (ArcGIS desktop10) for our users. We use it for create maps, when we want to publish that maps and services by licensed ArcGIS for server 9.3 , we first convert MXD (version 10) to version (9.3) then publish it, The problem is we m

Copyright (C) 2017 ceus-now.com, All Rights Reserved. webmaster#ceus-now.com 14 q. 0.313 s.